The principles behind Photovoltaic Solar Thermal Technology are the same.

They both absorb raw energy from the sun and convert it into electricity. However, there are a few key differences between these two technologies that make one more efficient than the other.

Solar Thermal Vs Photovoltaic PV

Solar Thermal

Solar Thermal technology has a higher space efficiency than Photovoltaic technology because it can capture more of the sun’s energy.

Solar Thermal systems can reach temperatures of up to 75 degrees Celsius, but temperatures over 500 degrees Celsius are possible with concentrating solar power.

Solar thermal energy is primarily used to heat water. It’s a basic system: the collectors on your roof are responsible for converting sunlight into heat, which is then sent through the tubes and into your cylinder for usage.

Solar thermal advantages:

Reduce your energy bills

A Solar Thermal system will help you save money on your energy bills by reducing the amount of energy you need to buy in order to produce hot water.

A typical solar thermal system includes panels or ‘collectors’ installed on your roof that absorb solar heat.

Related: Here’s How Solar Panels Are Installed

Become eco-friendly

If you have a solar thermal system fitted to your property, you are doing your bit to help the environment and become more eco-friendly.

Solar thermal systems do not produce any emissions or pollution, making them a great way of reducing your carbon footprint.

Reduce your carbon footprint

Solar thermal systems can reduce your carbon footprint. This is because they do not produce any emissions or pollution, making them a great way of reducing your carbon footprint.

Save extra money

Solar thermal systems can save you money in the long run. This is because they will reduce your energy bills, and you may be eligible for government incentives such as the Smart Export Guarantee (SEG).

Improve your home efficiency

Solar thermal systems are a more environmentally friendly, less expensive, and more efficient way to heat your water at home.

A solar thermal system usually includes solar collectors (evacuated tubes or flat plate collectors), a pump, and a twin coil hot water cylinder that serves as a thermal reservoir.

This makes them more efficient than traditional methods of heating water, such as gas or oil boilers.

Solar thermal disadvantages:

  • Installation is expensive.
  • Cannot be used during the night.
  • Hot water cannot be stored for very long.
  • Solar thermal is less efficient in winter.
  • Limited availability of installers.
  • Domestic solar thermal systems cannot generate power.

Installation is expensive

Like any type of solar installation, solar thermal systems can be expensive to install. The cost of installation will depend on the size and type of system you choose.

Cannot be used during the night

Solar thermal systems rely on sunlight to heat water, so they cannot be used at night or during periods of cloudy weather.

Hot water cannot be stored for very long

While hot water may be stored, it must be maintained at a constant temperature and prepared for usage.

Water in domestic hot water systems is maintained at a particular temperature using frequent cycles.

The issue with solar thermal installations is that they can’t keep the water warm during the night.

Because of this disadvantage, if your system lacks an immersion or a backup heater, you will likely run out of hot water within several hours after the sun sets.

Solar PV, on the other hand, is able to store energy in battery packs for later use.

Thermal solar panels cost

Solar thermal system costs vary, but the most common range from £3,000 to £6,000 (including a reduced VAT rate of 5%) for installation.

These figures include only installation expenses and component costs (solar collectors, control panel, pipes, and hot water tank).

The cost of your system will be determined by the type and grade of products you choose, as well as the size of your installation.

Related: How Much Do Solar Panel Systems Cost?

Is Solar Thermal Worth It?

If you have the right type of property and you are looking for a more environmentally friendly way to heat your water, then solar thermal could be worth considering.

The only downside is they fact that you can only heat your hot water during the daytime and you need to have a backup system for the evenings and cloudy days.

Photovoltaic PV

Photovoltaic (PV) systems, also known as solar panels are made of semiconducting materials like silicon that can directly convert sunlight into electricity.

PV systems are increasingly being used in a variety of applications, including homes, businesses, and utilities.

Related: Advantages And Disadvantages Of Solar Photovoltaic

How do PV cells work?

PV cells work by absorbing sunlight and converting it into electricity. The photons in sunlight knock electrons loose from the atoms in the PV cell, which generates an electrical current.

Photovoltaic advantages:

  • A clean and green energy source.
  • Low in maintenance.
  • Modular and scalable.
  • Can generate electricity even on cloudy days.
  • PV cells have a long lifetime.
  • Can be used in combination with other renewable energy sources.

A clean and green energy source

Photovoltaic (PV) systems are one of the greenest, most eco-friendly energy sources available.

PV cells don’t produce any harmful emissions or pollutants, making them a clean energy source.

Low in maintenance

Once a PV system is installed, it requires very little maintenance. PV cells are rugged and can withstand harsh weather conditions.

They just need to be cleaned every 6 months with deionized water and a soft cloth or brush.

If you are not able to do this yourself, most window cleaners using pure water technology can clean them for you.

Modular and scalable

PV systems are modular, meaning they can be easily expanded by adding more PV modules (solar panels).

This makes them a scalable technology that can be adapted to changing energy needs.

Can generate electricity even on cloudy days

PV cells can still generate electricity on cloudy days, although at a reduced rate.

This is because PV cells rely on daylight, not direct sunlight, to generate electricity.

PV cells have a long lifetime

PV cells have an expected lifespan of 20-25 years.

This means that once a PV system is installed, it will continue to generate electricity for many years.

Can be used in combination with other renewable energy sources

PV systems can be used in combination with other renewable energy sources, such as wind turbines or solar thermal systems.

This helps to create a more diversified and reliable energy supply.

Photovoltaic disadvantages:

  • The initial cost of PV systems is high.
  • PV cells are less efficient in converting sunlight to electricity.
  • Intermittency issues.
  • Less reliable power option.
  • Solar Energy Storage Is Expensive.
  • Uses a Lot of Space.
  • Associated with Pollution.

The initial cost of PV systems is high

Installing a PV system is a major investment. The cost of PV modules has fallen dramatically in recent years, but the cost of installation and other associated expenses (such as batteries) are still high.

PV cells are less efficient in converting sunlight to electricity

Solar cell efficiency varies with the type of semiconductor material and PV cell technology. PV modules had an average efficiency of less than 10% in the mid-1980s, rose to around 15% by 2015, and are approaching 20% for state-of-the-art modules today.

Unfortunately, PV cells are not as efficient as solar thermal systems in converting sunlight to heat.

Intermittency issues

PV systems are intermittent, meaning they only generate electricity when the sun is shining. This can be a problem if you need a constant supply of electricity, such as for a business or hospital.

Solar energy storage is expensive

Storing solar energy for use during the night or on cloudy days is currently very expensive.

This is because the batteries needed to store solar energy are still quite costly.

Uses a lot of space

PV systems require a lot of space to generate a significant amount of electricity. This can be a problem if you have limited space, such as on a rooftop.

Associated with pollution

While PV cells don’t produce any emissions, the manufacturing process of PV modules can create pollution.

This is because making solar cells requires large amounts of energy and produces hazardous waste.

Photovoltaic PV cost

Solar panels may cost anything from £2,900 to £6,700, based on data from the Energy Saving Trust.

Solar system prices range widely: £9,000 is not uncommon. The typical three-bedroom home requires a £4,800 system that includes 10 solar modules and consumes about 20 m² of roof space.

Is Photovoltaic PV Worth It?

Yes, Solar photovoltaic (PV) panels have been getting cheaper and more efficient for years. They’re now a firm favorite with homeowners looking to cut their energy bills and do their bit for the environment.

The initial cost of solar PV is still relatively high compared to other energy-saving measures such as loft insulation or draught-proofing.

But the cost of solar PV has fallen by around 70% since 2010, according to government figures.

And with the average domestic solar PV system now generating annual savings of 20% ROI in the first year, it’s no wonder solar PV is becoming an increasingly popular home improvement.

Photovoltaic Vs Solar Thermal Technology Which is Better?

Solar power has several advantages over solar thermal energy. Solar PV, on the other hand, generates electricity, whereas solar thermal is used to heat water or air.

This allows homeowners with solar PV systems to sell excess power back to the grid and earn a secondary revenue stream.

Solar thermal is more efficient at converting sunlight to heat than solar PV, making it the better choice if your main aim is to reduce your reliance on conventional heating systems such as gas or oil.

Solar thermal is also a cheaper option up front, with the average domestic solar thermal system costing around £4,000.

So, which technology is right for you? If you’re looking to generate electricity and cut your energy bills, then solar PV is the way to go.

If you’re more interested in reducing your reliance on fossil fuels for heating, then solar thermal could be the better option.

About the Author

Passionate about helping households transition to sustainable energy with helpful information and resources.

{"email":"Email address invalid","url":"Website address invalid","required":"Required field missing"}